Strategic Analysis
A comprehensive comparison of career and engagement platforms—and why The College Athlete Network is the only solution built around the athlete network graph.
Request a DemoStudent-athletes represent a uniquely valuable talent pool: disciplined, coachable, and trained in leadership and teamwork. Yet the infrastructure to connect athletes with career opportunities—and to sustain that connection after graduation—remains fragmented. Most universities rely on general career platforms, engagement tools, or manual spreadsheets. None are designed around the athlete network graph.
This analysis compares three approaches: Handshake (the dominant career-center job board), Athlete Network and UNITE (athletic department engagement platforms), and The College Athlete Network (athlete professional network infrastructure). The conclusion is clear: athlete career outcomes require a specialized network architecture that only CAN provides.
Universities today face a patchwork of solutions. Career services deploy generic job bulletin boards—Handshake and others—where postings are not specific to a user's university and applications are cold. No one likes these: they lack the warmth and specificity of an in-network introduction. Athletic departments deploy engagement platforms and alumni communication tools. Neither constructs a true athlete professional network—a roster-based graph that maps athletes to alumni, employers, and career outcomes, and that enables warm intros and hiring within the network.
The gap matters. Athletes change jobs every 3.1 years on average in the first 15 years post-graduation. For a network of 3,000 athletes, that means roughly 1,200 updates annually. No career office or athletic department has the bandwidth to maintain that data. The platforms that could help either don't provide the data or require the institution to supply it. The College Athlete Network is the exception: we provide the data. We maintain it. The institution gets the network.
Handshake is the largest career network for higher education. It powers career offices at 1,400+ universities and connects students with 750,000+ employers. Approximately 20 million students and alumni use the platform. Schools joining Handshake see on average a 3x increase in employer network size and diversity.
Target audience: Career centers, employers, and the general student population. Handshake is built for broad job-matching—not athlete-specific identity or alumni-athlete networks.
Data model: Students self-report resume data, major, graduation year, skills, and job preferences. The platform provides job listings, employer events, and recruiting workflows. Data is self-reported and structurally flat—there is no institutional roster, no sport identity, and weak alumni persistence.
Strategic positioning: Handshake is a generic job bulletin board. Postings are not specific to a user's university or network. Students apply cold—no warm intro from a fellow alum or teammate. Employers get volume; students get noise. No one likes generic bulletin boards because they lack the specificity and trust of an in-network introduction.
For athletic departments seeking a dedicated athlete network with warm intros and university-specific matching, Handshake is the wrong tool.
Athlete Network provides UNITE software—a digital engagement platform for current and former student-athletes. It serves athletic departments at colleges, universities, high schools, and associations. Programs including USC, Vanderbilt, Michigan, Penn State, Virginia Tech, Indiana, and Clemson use UNITE.
Target audience: Athletic departments, alumni engagement teams, and athlete communities. UNITE is built for communication, events, and engagement—not for constructing a professional network graph.
Features: Branded landing pages, career resources, mentorship programs, event management, e-learning, messaging, and analytics. The platform connects current and alumni athletes in communities and facilitates peer-to-peer networking.
Data model: Athlete participation, school affiliation, and community membership are required from users. The platform provides engagement content, mentoring workflows, and career resources. It is primarily communication infrastructure—not a data-provided network. The institution or users supply the data; UNITE organizes the experience.
Recruiting model: Career resources and employer access are typically generic—not a university-specific matching system that produces warm intros from within the athlete network.
The College Athlete Network builds cross-sport athlete professional networks inside universities. We source current and historic public athlete rosters, map athletes to third-party datasets (including LinkedIn), and refresh employer, title, and location data every 60 days. The result is an institutional athlete network graph that the university owns—without maintaining it.
Availabilities & Opportunities—pioneered by CAN: The College Athlete Network pioneered the matching of students and alumni posting "Availabilities" (what they're looking for—jobs, internships, mentorship, advice) with alumni posting "Opportunities" (what they're offering—roles, mentorship, intros). We are the Match.com for activating your network to hire within your network. Unlike generic job bulletin boards, every match is university-specific and network-native.
Warm intros, not cold applications: CAN provides users the warm intro. Alumni at target employers can be identified; pathways through mutual connections are visible. Students don't apply into a void—they connect through a fellow athlete who can vouch for them. That is the difference between a bulletin board and a network.
Target audience: Athletes, athlete alumni, athletic department leadership, development officers, and corporate employers seeking athlete talent. CAN is built exclusively for the athlete network.
Data model: CAN provides the data—official rosters, athlete identity, sport, team membership, alumni career data, and employer mapping. We do not ask users to build the network. We deliver it. This produces a true institutional athlete network graph that no other platform offers.
Handshake network structure: Student profile → employer job posting → job application. A generic bulletin board. Postings are not university-specific. Applications are cold. No warm intro. The graph is applicant-centric—there is no roster, no sport, no alumni-athlete identity.
Athlete Network structure: Athlete community → communication hub → engagement programs. The graph is community-centric. It organizes people for engagement but does not map them to employers, career outcomes, or a searchable professional network. Career resources are typically generic, not network-native matching.
College Athlete Network structure: Athlete roster → sport → university → athlete alumni → companies → career outcomes. Plus: Availabilities (students/alumni post what they need) ↔ Opportunities (alumni post what they offer). CAN pioneered this matching model—the Match.com for hiring within your network. The graph is roster-based, institution-owned, and university-specific. Every match produces a warm intro path. The roster-based network graph is fundamentally stronger because it reflects institutional reality and enables in-network hiring—not cold applications to generic job boards.
| Dimension | Handshake | Athlete Network | College Athlete Network |
|---|---|---|---|
| Data required from users | Resume, major, graduation year, skills, preferences | Athlete participation, school affiliation, community membership | None—we provide the data |
| Data provided by platform | Job listings, employer events, recruiting | Engagement content, mentoring, career resources | Rosters, athlete identity, sport, alumni career data, employer mapping |
| Data structure | Self-reported, limited structural identity | Communication infrastructure | Institutional athlete network graph |
| Data maintenance | User-maintained profiles | Institution or user-supplied | Platform-maintained, refreshed every 60 days |
| Matching / intro type | Generic bulletin board, cold applications | Generic career resources | Availabilities ↔ Opportunities, warm intros, university-specific |
This distinction is critical. Handshake and Athlete Network require users or institutions to supply and maintain data. The College Athlete Network provides and maintains the data. Data curation is 99% of the problem—and CAN owns it. That is why the network works.
Handshake: Universities → employers → job listings. Value accrues from employer density and job volume. Alumni persistence is weak; the platform optimizes for current-student recruiting.
Athlete Network: Athletes → engagement → alumni communication. Value accrues from community participation and event attendance. The network is engagement-driven, not career-outcome-driven.
College Athlete Network: Athletes → alumni athletes → corporate employers → career outcomes → stronger alumni engagement → stronger athletic programs. The athlete-to-athlete alumni network is uniquely powerful. Alumni athletes have stronger affinity bonds than general alumni. When they hire, mentor, or advise fellow athletes, the network compounds. Career outcomes drive engagement; engagement drives giving; giving strengthens the program.
Handshake buyers: Career services. The platform serves the career center. Athletic departments are not the primary stakeholder.
Athlete Network buyers: Athletic departments and alumni engagement teams. The platform serves communication and community.
College Athlete Network buyers: Athletic directors, development officers, alumni relations, NIL leadership, and corporate partnership teams. CAN aligns with more powerful decision makers inside universities. It delivers institutional ownership, fundraising narrative, and career outcomes—all from one platform.
Athletes and athlete alumni require a specialized network that general career platforms cannot provide. Reasons include:
The College Athlete Network is materially better for student athletes, athlete alumni, athletic department leadership, development officers, and universities building alumni engagement because it is the only platform designed around the athlete network graph.
| Dimension | Handshake | Athlete Network | College Athlete Network |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target users | Career centers, employers, general students | Athletic departments, athlete communities | Athletes, alumni, ADs, development, employers |
| Data structure | Self-reported profiles | User/institution-supplied | Platform-provided, institutional graph |
| Network graph | Student → job → employer | Community → engagement | Roster → sport → alumni → employers → outcomes |
| Matching model | Generic job bulletin board, cold applications | Career resources, generic employer access | Availabilities ↔ Opportunities (pioneered by CAN), warm intros, hire within network |
| Recruiting workflows | Volume job matching, not university-specific | Career resources, employer access | Athlete talent pool, warm intros, employer mapping |
| Alumni engagement | Weak persistence | Communication, events | Identity by sport, career mapping, mentorship, hiring |
| Athlete identity mapping | None | Community membership | Roster, sport, team, alumni, employer |
| Employer targeting | Broad job postings | National/regional employers | Athlete-specific talent, alumni at employers |
| Institutional value | Career center tool | Engagement platform | Athlete network infrastructure |
Handshake and similar platforms are generic job bulletin boards—not university-specific, no warm intro. Athlete Network is an engagement platform. The College Athlete Network is athlete professional network infrastructure—the only solution built around the roster-based athlete network graph, with data provided and maintained by the platform.
CAN pioneered Availabilities and Opportunities—the Match.com for activating your network to hire within your network. We provide users the warm intro. The others do not. No one likes generic bulletin boards. Everyone values a warm intro from within their network.
For universities serious about athlete career outcomes, alumni engagement, and fundraising sustainability, CAN is the materially superior choice. We don't ask you to build the network. We deliver it—and we deliver the warm intro.
Request a Demo